This problem asks for the kth smallest subarray sum. A naive approach would involve generating all subarrays, calculating their sums, sorting them, and then selecting the kth element. This is inefficient, with a time complexity that's at least O(n³), where n is the length of the input array nums
. A much more efficient solution utilizes binary search and a helper function to count subarrays with sums less than or equal to a given value.
Approach:
Binary Search: The core idea is to perform a binary search on the range of possible subarray sums. The minimum possible sum is the minimum element in nums
, and the maximum possible sum is the total sum of all elements in nums
.
Counting Function (f): A crucial helper function f(s)
counts the number of subarrays whose sum is less than or equal to s
. This function uses a sliding window technique. It iterates through the array, maintaining a window whose sum is less than or equal to s
. When the window sum exceeds s
, the left side of the window is moved to reduce the sum. The cnt
variable keeps track of the total number of such subarrays found.
Binary Search Logic: The binary search repeatedly checks a midpoint mid
as a potential kth smallest sum. If f(mid)
(the count of subarrays with sums ≤ mid
) is greater than or equal to k
, it means the kth smallest sum is less than or equal to mid
, so we search in the lower half. Otherwise, the kth smallest sum must be greater than mid
, and we search in the upper half.
Result: The binary search continues until l
and r
converge, at which point l
holds the kth smallest subarray sum.
Time Complexity Analysis:
f(s)
function takes O(n) time in the worst case (it iterates through the array once).Space Complexity Analysis:
The space complexity is O(1) because the algorithm uses only a constant amount of extra space.
Code Explanation (Python):
class Solution:
def kthSmallestSubarraySum(self, nums: List[int], k: int) -> int:
def f(s):
t = j = 0 # t: current window sum, j: left pointer of the window
cnt = 0 # count of subarrays with sum <= s
for i, x in enumerate(nums):
t += x
while t > s: # Shrink the window if sum exceeds s
t -= nums[j]
j += 1
cnt += i - j + 1 # Add the count of subarrays ending at index i
return cnt
l, r = min(nums), sum(nums) # Initialize the search range
# Using bisect_left for efficiency instead of a while loop
return l + bisect_left(range(l, r + 1), True, key=f)
The Python code efficiently uses bisect_left
from the bisect
module to perform the binary search, making the code more concise and potentially faster than an explicit while
loop implementation. The key=f
argument tells bisect_left
to use the result of the f
function as the comparison key during the search.
The other languages (Java, C++, Go) follow a similar logic, implementing the binary search and the counting function explicitly using while
loops. The core algorithm remains the same across all languages.